Jacques Nack, Chief Innovation Officer at iDiscovery Solutions, is a trailblazer in cloud security, compliance, and risk management.
In the world of digital marketing, tracking pixels have long been the secret sauce for companies trying to understand their customers. These tiny, invisible bits of code are embedded in websites and emails, quietly collecting data about what users click, where they scroll and how long they linger. For businesses, this data is gold—fueling personalized ads and optimizing campaigns in ways that feel almost magical. But for consumers, it’s starting to feel more like a privacy nightmare.
The problem isn’t the pixels themselves. It’s the way companies are using them—without proper disclosure, without explicit consent and sometimes without even realizing the full scope of what these pixels are collecting. And now, regulators and consumers alike are fighting back. From multimillion-dollar fines to class-action lawsuits to public outrage, the consequences of mishandling tracking pixels are piling up fast. And in 2025, failing to get this right could cost companies more than just money—it could cost them their reputation.
The Pixel Problem
Here’s how it works: A tracking pixel is a tiny image or piece of code that collects data when a user visits a website or opens an email. It can tell businesses whether you clicked on an ad, added something to your cart, or abandoned it halfway through checkout. It’s a marketer’s dream tool—until it isn’t.
Take GoodRx, for example. The popular prescription discount platform was caught sharing sensitive health information with advertising giants like Google and Facebook through tracking pixels. Users had no idea their prescription searches were being turned into targeted ads. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) wasn’t thrilled either. Earlier this year, it slapped GoodRx with a $1.5 million fine and banned the company from sharing health data for advertising purposes ever again.
GoodRx isn’t alone. BetterHelp, an online therapy platform, faced a similar reckoning when it was revealed that it had shared therapy-related data with third parties via tracking pixels. The fallout? A $7.8 million settlement and a PR disaster that left users questioning whether their most personal struggles were being sold to the highest bidder.
Lawsuits Are Just The Beginning
If regulators don’t get your attention, lawsuits might. In California, where privacy laws like the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) and its successor, the California Privacy Rights Act (CPRA), have set the gold standard for consumer protection, companies are finding themselves in hot water over undisclosed pixel usage.
Take The Boston Globe. The newspaper was accused of using Meta’s tracking pixels to share subscribers’ personally identifiable information (PII) with Facebook—without their consent. While the company denied wrongdoing, it still settled for $5 million and agreed to suspend pixel usage on certain pages.
And then there’s the healthcare sector. A report last year found that one-third of top U.S. hospitals were using tracking pixels that shared patient data with social media platforms like Facebook. The backlash was swift and brutal, with hospitals scrambling to remove pixels from their websites amid growing public outrage.
These cases highlight a harsh reality: Even if a company isn’t intentionally misusing data, failing to disclose how it’s collected can lead to massive legal and reputational fallout.
Why Consumers Are Fed Up
The rise of privacy laws like CCPA and CPRA didn’t happen in a vacuum. They’re a direct response to growing consumer frustration over how their data is being used—and abused.
A 2024 Cisco survey found that 75% of consumers refuse to do business with companies they don’t trust with their data. And trust is hard to rebuild once it’s broken. When users discover that their personal information has been collected without their knowledge—or worse, shared with third parties—they feel betrayed.
This erosion of trust doesn’t just hurt consumers; it hurts businesses too. Companies that mishandle privacy risk losing customers to competitors who prioritize transparency and respect for user data.
The Cost of Getting It Wrong
The financial toll of mishandling tracking pixels goes far beyond regulatory fines and lawsuit settlements:
• Lost Customers: Privacy-conscious consumers are quick to abandon brands they perceive as careless with their data.
• Reputational Damage: Negative headlines about privacy violations can tarnish a company’s image for years.
• Operational Disruption: Removing improperly implemented pixels or reconfiguring systems to comply with regulations can be costly and time-consuming.
For businesses that rely heavily on digital marketing—and let’s face it, who doesn’t these days?—the stakes couldn’t be higher.
How To Get It Right
So what’s the solution? Transparency is key. Companies need to stop treating privacy as an afterthought and start making it a core part of their strategy.
Here are some best practices:
- Disclose Everything: If you’re using tracking pixels, say so—loudly and clearly—in your privacy policy.
- Get Consent: Use cookie banners or pop-ups to inform users about pixel usage before collecting any data.
- Limit Data Collection: Only collect what you absolutely need—and nothing more.
- Audit Regularly: Conduct periodic reviews of your pixel configurations to ensure compliance with evolving regulations.
- Educate Your Users: Help consumers understand how tracking technologies work and why they’re used.
Companies that take these steps won’t just avoid lawsuits—they’ll build trust with their customers at a time when trust is more valuable than ever.
The Bottom Line
Tracking pixels aren’t going away anytime soon. They’re too valuable for businesses looking to stay competitive in an increasingly digital world. But as recent scandals have shown, using these tools without proper disclosure is a recipe for disaster.
In 2025, privacy isn’t just about compliance—it’s about survival. Companies that prioritize transparency and respect for user data will come out ahead, while those that cut corners will find themselves paying the price—in courtrooms, in headlines, and in lost customer loyalty.
The choice is clear: Get your pixel game together or risk becoming the next cautionary tale in the ongoing saga of digital privacy gone wrong.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
