Buy now, pay later (BNPL) broke onto the scene as a payment method in the past few years with the premise that it’s superior to credit cards because it promises not to charge interest, and can break larger sums into smaller, more manageable payments.
Find Out: 5 ‘Necessities’ Frugal People Don’t Buy, According to Frugal Living Expert Austin Williams
Advertisement: High Yield Savings Offers
Read Next: The New Retirement Problem Boomers Are Facing
It’s become a popular form of payment, as evidenced by a Lending Tree survey that found that 25% of respondents are buying their groceries this way (up from 14% in 2024).
Christopher Stroup, CFP and owner of Silicon Beach Financial, warned that BNPL may seem like a better deal, but it actually isn’t.
BNPL turns recurring expenses into future debt, Stroup warned.
“When you’re financing perishable goods, you’re committing income you haven’t yet earned to purchases you’ve already consumed.”
This leaves you vulnerable to overdrafts, missed payments and a cycle of dependence on short-term credit.
Check Out: 5 Frugal Habits Suze Orman Still Follows Even Though She Can Afford Almost Anything
BNPL can also encourage overspending “by minimizing the psychological pain of paying,” Stroup said. It may feel like a “free solution,” but late fees, overdraft charges and the risk of stacking debt across platforms can quietly destabilize your finances, especially when used for nondiscretionary items like groceries.
Another problem is that frequent BNPL use “can fragment your budget and obscure your true cash flow,” Stroup said.
Many services don’t report on-time payments but will report missed ones, which hurts your credit. Over time, this erodes your ability to plan, save and invest with intention.
While “zero percent” is tempting, Stroup said it doesn’t mean zero risk. “You’re still creating debt. Miss one payment and you may face fees or credit damage.”
Plus, relying on BNPL for essentials is likely a sign of a deeper cash flow problem that needs solving, not financing.
Before leaping onto a BNPL solution, Stroup urged consumers to start with a clear budget that prioritizes essentials.
Use things like cash-back debit cards or high-yield checking accounts for everyday spending. Explore local food co-ops or assistance programs.
“If cash flow is consistently tight, revisit fixed expenses or negotiate recurring bills before reaching for credit,” he said.
Support yourself with budgeting, shopping or spending tools like YNAB, Goodbudget or Rocket Money to help track spending and set grocery limits, he said.
