Gianluca Sidoti is an Independent Financial Advisor, Founder of TraDetector and Managing Partner at Citadines Capital SCF.
For many Americans, buying a home is a dream come true. Whether it’s a deeply rooted cultural tradition or a symbol of personal achievement, owning a property remains a top priority for many savers. This desire is often driven by a strong emotional attachment to the idea of “owning a home,” a concept deeply embedded in the country’s social and cultural fabric. Homeownership is seen not just as a financial investment but also as a way to achieve stability and security for oneself and one’s family.
If you’ve decided that buying a home is the right choice for you, it’s crucial to approach this decision thoughtfully. Purchasing a property is one of the most significant financial decisions in a person’s life and requires a comprehensive evaluation of your financial situation. It’s not just about picking your dream house; it’s a step that must be well-planned to avoid future financial difficulties. By adopting a few simple but valuable rules, you can make sure this decision is sustainable long-term and avoid common mistakes that could jeopardize your financial stability.
The Impact Of Property On Total Wealth
A key principle of wealth management is diversification. Buying a home can significantly impact a person’s financial resources, concentrating a substantial portion of their assets in one nonliquid asset. Unlike productive investments, such as stocks or bonds that generate passive income, a home is primarily a consumption asset—it may appreciate over time but does not guarantee returns. Moreover, real estate markets can be unpredictable and influenced by economic, political and environmental factors that can affect property values.
For this reason, homeownership must represent only a portion of your overall wealth. A general guideline suggests not allocating more than 50% of your total assets to real estate. However, I often propose to my clients a more conservative approach: The value of the home you live in should not exceed 30% of your total assets. If you have $300,000 in savings and investments, your home should not be worth more than $100,000. This rule helps maintain financial flexibility and reduces risk.
Moreover, ideally, you should be able to purchase your home without needing a mortgage. This doesn’t mean you must avoid loans altogether, but you should have the capability, in theory, to buy the home outright. Whether you choose to take a mortgage depends on various factors, such as income, savings trends, investment portfolio and personal financial goals.
A few years ago, I helped a client purchase his retirement home. He had a salary of barely $100,000 a year and liquid assets of $2 million. He was convinced that he could buy using his savings, but considering the net return on his portfolio (an average of 7% per year), we opted for a 15-year mortgage so that he would be able to pay installments and interest with the earnings from his investments.
Managing Asset Imbalance
If you’ve already purchased a home and find that it represents a significant portion of your wealth (e.g., 70%-80%), it’s important to rebalance your portfolio. In such cases, prioritizing saving and investing becomes crucial to restoring the balance between real estate and other financial assets. Diversifying into more liquid investments, such as government bonds or mutual funds, can help spread risk and enhance overall financial stability.
Debt And Sustainable Home Purchase
Debt is another critical factor to consider when buying a home. Many first-time buyers finance their purchase with a mortgage, taking on significant debt. To ensure the purchase is sustainable, it’s vital to avoid excessive borrowing. Ideally, you should be able to finance at least half of the home purchase without depleting your liquid reserves. This ensures financial flexibility for emergencies or other opportunities.
A general rule of thumb is that mortgage payments should not exceed one-third of your monthly income. If you find yourself needing a 25- or 30-year mortgage to make payments manageable, it may indicate the purchase isn’t financially sustainable, as this extends debt over a long period and increases the risk of default in case of changes in personal or economic circumstances.
It is also essential to understand that comparing the cost of a mortgage to rent payments is not always straightforward. While rent might seem like “throwing money away” because it doesn’t lead to ownership, a mortgage is a long-term financial commitment that comes with additional risks. The mortgage payment should be evaluated not only in terms of the amount but also in relation to the risk and overall financial stability.
Factors To Consider Before Buying A Home
Before proceeding with a home purchase, it’s essential to consider factors that affect the investment’s sustainability and timing:
Family Planning
Plans to expand the family or accommodate growing children can impact housing needs and financial priorities.
Income Stability
A stable job with growth prospects may justify a larger investment, whereas uncertain income situations require caution.
Life Expectancy
Usually, I advise young people against buying a house to live in, because having their whole lives ahead of them, it is difficult to predict where they will be in 20 years.
Tax Implications
Consult a tax advisor to understand how buying a home will affect your taxes and explore any available homeowner tax benefits.
Maintaining Liquidity
Ensure sufficient liquid resources remain after the purchase to handle emergencies or capitalize on investment opportunities.
Conclusion: Making An Informed Decision
Buying a home is a major decision that requires balancing emotional desires with a solid financial analysis. It’s important not to let emotions drive the decision entirely. Statements like “renting is wasting money” or “houses always appreciate” are often based on unverified assumptions and can lead to poorly thought-out decisions. Ultimately, buying a home can be a rewarding experience, but only if approached with proper preparation and a robust financial plan. Take the necessary time to consider all options and make sure this decision supports your long-term security and stability.
The information provided here is not investment, tax or financial advice. You should consult with a licensed professional for advice concerning your specific situation.
Forbes Finance Council is an invitation-only organization for executives in successful accounting, financial planning and wealth management firms. Do I qualify?
