As CTO of Engage People Inc. Len Covello helps companies differentiate loyalty programs to deliver a better experience for their customers.
Value has quickly become the foundation of the retail industry. After years of high inflation, economic uncertainty and retail evolution, people are focusing on value when they decide where, how and when to shop.
This year, consumers are trading down, reducing impulse purchases and waiting for promotions before hitting the checkout counter. In a shopper survey by RetailNext cited by Forbes, 71% of respondents said that retailers should prioritize lowering prices this year.
Accepting a pay with points (PwP) process from a number of loyalty programs is an opportunity for retailers to deliver value while also increasing engagement, conversion rates, purchase frequency and overall satisfaction.
PwP became a form of currency in an increasingly cost-conscious society. Viewed as a financial utility, rather than an accrued reward, loyalty points become a vehicle for value delivery. Based on my role managing PwP software, here is a closer look at how value is redefining the retail sector and how loyalty is becoming a means to deliver it.
Redefining The Relationship Between Value And Loyalty
Value isn’t simply affordability. While people are becoming more discerning about product prices, true value transcends the price tag.
According to a 2026 retail report from Deloitte, shoppers are redefining value as a complete shopping experience, not just a lower price. The survey shows that 40% of consumers now believe that a brand’s value stems from characteristics other than price. As a result, brands can focus on ease of checkout, customer service and loyalty programs to deliver value.
This is not a temporary response to high inflation. Rather, Deloitte’s research calls this a structural change in shopping habits. The change is happening across the spectrum; even high-income households are becoming more intentional and strategic about spending.
To compete in a cost-conscious economy, retailers need to embrace value as an experience. A PwP loyalty program can help deliver that experience. It can provide an immediate opportunity for savings at checkout and help stretch purchasing power further. This can make a meaningful difference at the point of sale, increasing conversion rates and strengthening the connection between the brand and the customer.
The transaction delivers the value that consumers want in today’s economy, and the right loyalty program is able to repeat the cycle. Shoppers are no longer only accruing points over the long term. Rather, the frequency of the reward leads to greater gratification. Frequent redemption has the potential to significantly increase engagement in a loyalty program and strengthen the value cycle. This is the modern-day value cycle.
How Consumer Demand Drives Change
The cost-conscious economy has put a spotlight on value, but careful spending habits are catalyzing an even deeper shift in spending behaviors. In addition to value, today’s shoppers are prioritizing convenience, versatility and brand connectivity. Customers want a frictionless retail journey from product selection to checkout.
In fact, surprise fees or friction during checkout increase instances of abandoned shopping carts, according to a UPS survey. To ease friction, PwP can transform loyalty points into a wallet-like balance that can be used at the consumer’s discretion to reduce purchase price or enhance value in the moment. Shoppers are empowered to engage with the program and receive the benefits as part of their daily spending, not as an aspirational reward that could otherwise take a significant amount of time to earn.
In Canada, Triangle Rewards is a quintessential example. The rewards program engages customers across several major brands, including Canadian Tire, Sport Chek and Party City, giving customers the opportunity to earn rewards on every purchase and redeem them instantly.
While there is no multi-brand equivalent in the U.S., programs like Kohl’s Rewards offer high percentage back on purchases and cash-like equivalent rewards that can be used at checkout.
Loyalty technology embedded into POS systems has allowed retailers to easily provide this experience, extending omnichannel cohesion. The technology creates the ability to use points instantly at checkout as another form of currency. Shoppers get complete control and access to their loyalty program and ultimately enhances engagement.
Some retailers have been slow to adapt to these fundamental shifts in consumer behavior, but understanding how the technology can improve the sales transaction has helped encourage a lot more retailers to create the utilitarian loyalty programs that people are seeking today.
Why Real-Time Value Is The New Standard
When PwP meets financial expediency, the result is real-time value, and that real-time value has become a new standard in the shopping experience.
Customers want it, and they know it when they see it. They encounter different iterations of loyalty every day in the stores they visit, and it is easy to see when loyalty is working and when it isn’t. Consumers know the points available to them and where they can most easily use those points to shape their retail journey and find value.
It’s clear to see this transition when you look at the way that major retailers are overhauling loyalty programs to big success. This year, Starbucks unveiled new benefits, like a free drink customization once a month, more opportunities for bonus points and exclusive and personalized offers, all with a goal of providing “more meaningful value,” “faster rewards” and “deepening connection.”
This program is responding to all of the standard characteristics expected in a modern loyalty program today to provide instant, real-time value from earned rewards. Starbucks isn’t alone. Wing Stop, The Gap, Ikea and other retailers are all reexamining loyalty to respond to evolving expectations, enhance value and expedite the earn-redeem reward cycle.
Real-time value is so ubiquitous that it transcends across retail verticals, from grocery and gas to clothing and beauty to quick service restaurants. When payment tools are available, whether using their checking account, savings or loyalty points, it is easier to decide on the purchase and it can lead to more conversions to sales.
The economy has evolved, and spending and shopping habits have evolved in step. Retailers should rethink their loyalty strategies to meet consumer expectations of providing real-time value and instant gratification.
Forbes Technology Council is an invitation-only community for world-class CIOs, CTOs and technology executives. Do I qualify?
